Originally posted by DemoN
WAR RULES
§6 Rating of War
A summary of the War will take place according to absolute loss of points. The Alliances have the responsibility of within 12 hours after the end of the War be declared, to organize and post on the Board all the relevant Battle Reports (and other relevant informations). Then, it will be calculated one ranking, according to the posted Battle Reports (BRs). After those 12 hours and the calculation of the statistics of the War the following posts with Battle Reports are not valid and will not be considered. The Name and Tag of the alliances involved should be written in the correct spelling (including members nicknames and the score after and before the war).
What is inside the "quote" in one of the options possible to decide who wins a War.
My point of view:
I don't agree with this rule. In my point of view the War Finishes when the leader of one Alliance surrender assuming that his Family assumes that has lost the War. The reasons for my point of view are:
* Sometimes an Alliance starts by loosing a War, gets a better strategy and starts recovering and approaching to be winners, even if they start as losers;
* The strategy of the Family that start the war "loosing" can be better and the other Family (that started the war winning) may start to be afraid of loosing more "points" or "units", so decides to declare themselves as losers (even if at the beginning they destroyed more troops to the Family enemy);
* If, like it says in the "quote" above, some person of the team have to make the counting of troops/points/whatever that each Family have lost, to declare a winner, it may mistake and it will take ages (considering that we don't even have a decent "Combat Packer", as I am concerned, it's humanly impossible or it will take ages, and the members of this Team already have too much work to be finished so far...)
So the question will be:
The decision about who wins a war should be:
1. After somebody calculates who lost more points/troops during that war.
2. When one of the Alliances declare itself as looser and the other Alliance accepts the "surrender".
ATTENTION: here just comments in English!
To the comments in other languages:
Português: [GUERRAS - Avaliação] Redefinição de Regras Capitulo 5
Español: [GUERRAS - Evaluación] Redefinición de Reglas Capítulo 5
Français: [GUERRES - Évaluation] Redéfinition des Regles Chapitre 5
Italiano: [GUERRA - Valutazione] Ridefinizione delle Regole Capitolo 5